Al Yellon
Editor
It's Gotta Be The Hair - May 15
Grant Brisbee
Editor
Tarasco Sauce - May 16
Jeff Sullivan
Editor
Mission Accomplished - May 16
Rob Neyer
National Baseball Editor
Baseball is Unpredictable - May 12
Dan Moore
Contributor
Joey Votto And The Twilight Of The Giant First Basemen - Apr 14
Jason Brannon
Hot Corner Scribe
Len Kasper Has Been Over Into The Future... - May 15
Jim Baker
Contributor
eBay Item Of The Day - May 15
Marc Normandin
Contributor
The Royals And Pitcher Development - May 15
Wendy Thurm
Contributor
On Being Young And Brash In The Social Media Age - May 12
Jun 29, 2011 - According to Jim Souhan, Joe Mauer is "the softest of stars" ... and wait, there's so much more. Just two snippets, for the flavor ...
That Mauer didn't start at catcher on Sunday wasn't a crime. His manager, Ron Gardenhire, is determined to protect Mauer's legs and back by keeping him from catching in day games following night games. Mauer didn't beg out of the game; Gardenhire never gave him the chance.
Mauer's crime is that he didn't volunteer to play first base for a team desperate for hitting, leaving Gardenhire to play Luke Hughes out of position at first.
--snip--
With his team desperate for runs and wins, Mauer has relaxed. That's why some of his teammates have been rolling their eyes this season whenever his name is mentioned.
He has proved to be the softest of stars, and if that wasn't bad enough, his $184 million contract could prevent the Twins from retaining a valuable veteran who plays whenever and wherever the Twins need him.
Later in the piece, Souhan compares Mauer (unfavorably, of course) to
- Michael Cuddyer, who happily plays 11 positions and is very close to curing colon cancer, and
- Alex Avila, a catcher who actually played one game at third base, once.
Look, I don't know if Joe Mauer is soft. I do know that a sportswriter can't have any real idea how badly a player is hurting. I also know that while a player's teammates might have some idea, they generally think no injury is serious unless it's their own. That's just human nature.
And of course, Mauer did try to play hurt, at the start of the season. That was a disaster.
Could he play first base? Sure. Anyone can play first base, right? Except every time I say that, someone tells me it's a lot harder than I think (which it is). Anyway, Mauer did take some grounders at first, Monday. He's a good athlete, when he's healthy anyway, and could probably do a passable job there with some practice.
That doesn't seem to me the issue. The issue is whether you want your best player, recovering from a mysterious-but-presumably-real-enough injury, playing more often than his doctors and his manager think advisable. With his team nowhere near first place, and the club's other superstar out until August.
And a question, too ... Did anyone now criticizing Joe Mauer, or questioning his $184 million contract, raise any objections in March 2010 when the deal was done? All I heard at the time was, "Yes it's a lot of money, but the Twins had to keep Mauer. He's a hometown guy!"
To Souhan's credit, he did mention the caveats. Just before the Twins locked up Mauer, Souhan wrote a long column that included this:
A public relations expert would urge the Twins to sign Mauer at any cost. A statistician or scout might argue that he might never duplicate his remarkable 2009 season, that he has been plagued by injuries, that the Twins are high on catching prospect Wilson Ramos, that the franchise might be better off spending the $200 million it might take to sign Mauer on a handful of other players.
So at least he's been consistent about the money.
I don't believe that Joe Mauer's soft. I don't believe Joe Mauer should consider "giving back some of those millions" (as the headline on Souhan's latest column suggests). I do believe, as Souhan believed a year ago, than committing nearly $200 million to a player coming off his best season was more than a little risky.
Obviously, any huge contract is a calculated risk. We just don't if the calculations were done correctly. And seeing as how 2011 is the first year of the contract -- which pays Mauer $23 million per year -- to this point the risk hasn't paid off.
For much more about Mauer and the Twins, please visit Twinkie Town.
6 comments
Mickey Hatcher, Angels Hitting Coach, Relieved Of Duties
Vance Worley Has 'Soreness', Will Miss Wednesday Start
Justin Morneau Will Be Activated From DL Wednesday
Manny Ramirez Rehab Assignment Will Start Saturday In Albuquerque
Jon Jay Heading To Disabled List; Shane Robinson Recalled
Troy Tulowitzki Day-To-Day With Deep Leg Bruise
Matt Kemp Goes On 15-Day DL With Sore Hamstring
Jeff Niemann Likely Missing 'A Few Months' With Leg Injury
VIDEO: Bryce Harper's First Career Home Run
Torii Hunter Placed On Restricted List Following Son's Arrest
More News »
Comments
Aristophenes
Ridiculous!
by jintman1 on Jun 29, 2011 3:24 PM EDT reply actions
Who would the Twins have signed with that $26 mill/year?
Jayson Werth and Carl Crawford haven’t exactly set the world on fire.
They say hindsight is 20/20, but this opinion seems myopic. Cuddyer’s not worth $10.5 million, no matter how well he hits lefties and where he plays.
by Mister_S on Jun 29, 2011 5:15 PM EDT reply actions
$23 per year. $184/8 years
by Luke in MN on Jun 29, 2011 8:28 PM EDT up reply actions
Giving Souhan credit
for anything is a dangerous path.
by Jesse on Jun 29, 2011 5:51 PM EDT reply actions
This must be what Jonah Lehrer likes.
Yesterday, in his straw man attack on sabermetrics, Jonah Lehrer argued that focusing on sabermetrics distorts a fan’s judgement about the game and that we should spend more time thinking about “intangibles.” Well, Souhan’s argument does that all right. Of course, in his case, “intangibles” are grounded in innuendo and armchair speculation about clubhouse ferment as always has been the case with hack sportswriters.
by jonathanmc on Jun 29, 2011 6:33 PM EDT reply actions 1 recs
Despite doing nothing in 2011 so far,
only Alex Rodriguez and Miguel Cabrera have more fWAR in the AL than Mauer since 2006 (rWAR is even more favorable to him IIRC). Morons like Souhan have been deriding Mauer as a soft “singles hitter” (singles are bad apparently) since he came up with the team. They loved setting up this straw man that Mauer has to hit like 2009 every year to be worth his contract and are constantly insinuating if not outright accusing him of dogging it, despite the fact that almost no one has caught more…oh christ, why do I even bother. There’s no arguing with these people.
by Luke in MN on Jun 29, 2011 8:35 PM EDT reply actions
Comments For This Post Are Closed