Al Yellon
Editor
It's Gotta Be The Hair - May 15
Grant Brisbee
Editor
Tarasco Sauce - May 16
Jeff Sullivan
Editor
Mission Accomplished - May 16
Rob Neyer
National Baseball Editor
Baseball is Unpredictable - May 12
Dan Moore
Contributor
Joey Votto And The Twilight Of The Giant First Basemen - Apr 14
Jim Baker
Contributor
eBay Item Of The Day - May 15
Marc Normandin
Contributor
The Royals And Pitcher Development - May 15
Wendy Thurm
Contributor
On Being Young And Brash In The Social Media Age - May 12
By Rob Neyer - National Baseball Editor
Follow @sbnbaseball on Twitter, and Like Baseball Nation on Facebook.
Apr 6, 2011 - Supposedly Steve Phillips said this last week on his XM Radio show:
While discussing the Barry Bonds perjury trial, Phillips went on to suggest that steroids helped the game.
"Thank God for steroids," he said. "It brought the game back from extinction."
If I may? No man or group of men, nor some muscle-building drug, has ever saved baseball.
Babe Ruth didn't save baseball, nor did Kennesaw Mountain Landis.
Mark McGwire and Sammy Sosa didn't save baseball, nor did Cal Ripken.
All of those might have, in some small degree, facilitated baseball's economic fortunes for short periods of time. But I will argue with virtually no reservation that if none of those men had been born, baseball today would be almost exactly what it is.
The game has always been bigger than any one man. Or even any two men, juiced up on 'roids.
Follow @sbnbaseball on Twitter, and Like Baseball Nation on Facebook.
5 comments
National Baseball Editor
Rob Neyer began his career with legendary baseball author Bill James, and later worked for STATS, Inc. and ESPN.com, writing more words for that website than anyone else. Rob has written or... Read full bio
SB Nation Profile
@robneyer
Subscribe to Rob Neyer
Mickey Hatcher, Angels Hitting Coach, Relieved Of Duties
Vance Worley Has 'Soreness', Will Miss Wednesday Start
Justin Morneau Will Be Activated From DL Wednesday
Manny Ramirez Rehab Assignment Will Start Saturday In Albuquerque
Jon Jay Heading To Disabled List; Shane Robinson Recalled
Troy Tulowitzki Day-To-Day With Deep Leg Bruise
Matt Kemp Goes On 15-Day DL With Sore Hamstring
Jeff Niemann Likely Missing 'A Few Months' With Leg Injury
VIDEO: Bryce Harper's First Career Home Run
Torii Hunter Placed On Restricted List Following Son's Arrest
More News »






Comments
I don’t understand why the players from that era are going to be crucified if this is the opinion of someone who was in a front office during that time. If he thinks this, why wouldn’t the players use steroids?
by Phildo on Apr 6, 2011 9:16 AM EDT reply actions
I do not condone steroid use but its use in baseball definitely coincides with other changes in the game over the years and I think it has contributed to baseball’s growth and entertainment value. Virtually every stadium in the US has seen their fences shortened for the simple fact that people would rather see more homeruns than pop flys.
Also just because a few guys have been called out for taking steroids doesn’t mean there isn’t a much larger population of athletes taking them, both minor and major leaguers, but especially minor leagers. There are certainly players that have amazing talent and are completely clean, but it would be naive to assume that there aren’t 100’s upon 100’s of players who have worked their way up using performance enhancing drugs. At the end of the day if you are getting paid to be the best, but you naturally can’t get there, you are going to take something (not my mindset, but I think many players struggle with this). So I definitely think it has changed the game, definitely increased entertainment value, but unfortunately has made some athletes terrible role models for young athletes.
by gckid on Apr 6, 2011 10:26 AM EDT reply actions
I understand that everyone’s experience is different but steroids in no way saved baseball for me. I didn’t watch baseball when I was young. I watched basketball and football but not baseball. That changed when I was nine when the Yankees played the Mariners in the 1995 playoffs. That series hooked me on baseball. I watched it with my father and during the games he told me about going to Yankee stadium and watching Mickey Mantle. I’ve been hooked ever since. And in 1998 at age 12 I rooted against Mcgwire because even at 12 I knew that a guy that had andro sitting in his locker was probably hitting some pharmaceutically induced home runs. And while Kennisaw Mountain Landis might have helped baseball after the black sox scandal his stance on black players denied Satchel Paige and Josh Gibson the chance to play against the best. So he might have done as much to damage the game as save it.
by Pflood83 on Apr 6, 2011 11:26 AM EDT reply actions
Show some commitment
Be a little more definitive, Rob.
1) Steve Phillips “supposedly” said… Did he say it, or didn’t he?
2) “virtually” no reservations. So, What are your reservations? Why can’t you say you have No Reservations Period. You should let us know why you can’t.
3) “Almost Exactly” in other words, it was different based on those players.
I agree with your original premise that these guys didn’t save baseball, it was never going anywhere, certainly not to extinction. BUT, then you changed to the idea that these guys had (as you put it) no significant effect on the popularity of the game. That’s just ignorant, and I don’t think you would really put your foot down on that point now that a light is shined on it. Would you?
by YleeXOtee on Apr 6, 2011 11:09 PM EDT reply actions
Jose Saves after Steroids Score
It brought the game back yes, but in a unhealthy and unrealistic way. Baseball is different from Beer League Softball just like legitimate Wrestling is different from the WWE. Baseball is on the right path, now if they could just decide whether or not to have a DH and contract to 28 teams we’d really have something but I digress. In all seriousness Jose Canseco saved baseball.
by Jeff-Ct on Apr 6, 2011 11:27 PM EDT reply actions
Comments For This Post Are Closed